Site Meter Encouraging Health » Blog Archive » Diets don’t work…Lifestyle Changes Do!

Diets don’t work…Lifestyle Changes Do!

by Brick ONeil

walking.jpg

This article over on WebMD.com, “Diets Don’t Work Long-Term”, by Daniel J. DeNoon, verifies what has been rumored over the internet for years.

Don’t start a diet if you’re not prepared to follow it for the rest of your life! Those ‘lose weight quick’ schemes are just that. You lose 10, 20, 30 pounds only to gain them back after a few months? Thats because we dont’ think ‘long term’.

“Traci Mann, PhD, associate professor of psychology at UCLA, was teaching a seminar on the psychology of eating when she noticed something odd about diet studies. Few of the studies followed up on dieters for more than six months. Even fewer followed dieters for a year or more.

Mann wondered what, in the long term, really happens when people go on diets. So she and her students tracked down 31 studies that, one way or another, had at least one year of follow-up data. They were interested in just one number: the percentage of dieters who, over time, gain back more weight than they lose.”

Traci Mann has this to say on the subject of long-term lifestyle changes and weight loss:
” Why don’t diets work? Mann says there are two issues. The first is that it’s just plain hard for people to change their eating behaviors. And the second reason is that even if you do succeed at a diet, the rule of diminishing returns comes into play.

“When you keep to a reduced-calorie diet, your body makes metabolic adjustments that make it harder and harder for you to lose weight,” Mann says. “Your body becomes very efficient, and you have to eat less and less to continue to lose weight. If you had the will to go on a diet, the fact that it steadily becomes less and less effective makes it even harder to stick to it.” ”

The article ends by this statement: “Elements of this lifestyle change, she says, include moderating food intake, increasing physical activity, managing stress without food, and getting treatment for depression and other illnesses that get in the way.

Even though diets don’t work all by themselves, Mann agrees that there’s much people can do.

“I am not saying ‘Don’t diet’ — I’m just saying people should try to eat healthy food in moderation and exercise like mad,” she says.”

Personally, I’ve lost weight by eating a more vegetarian diet, cutting out so much red meat and carbohydrates and calories, in addition to walking 30-45 minutes a day. I lost 20 lbs, but gained it back when events beyond my control had me reverting to comfort food for nearly six months.

For losing weight, contact your health care physicial, discuss what lifestyle changes meet your needs and start on a new life.

lifestyle change, lose weight, calories, carbohydrates, long term weight loss

, , , ,


3 Responses to “Diets don’t work…Lifestyle Changes Do!”

  1. Rick Says:

    I started Weight Watchers 6 weeks ago, and have lost 25 pounds so far. The best news is that I’m looking at this as a lifestyle change, and not a diet. I’m learning some new habits, not just postponing my old ones. And you brought up a great point about life situations that seem to overwhelm us. For me, it’s a matter of going into stressful situations with a plan, and also having somebody to be accountable to.

  2. Brick ONeil Says:

    Congratulations on your weight loss, Rick! It’s so gratifying to see someone enjoying their new, healthy lifestyle. Learning new habits is hard work, but worth it in the long run.

  3. Neel Says:

    Right on target! Diets have to be accompanied by changes in lifetyle. There simply is no short cut.

Leave a Reply


About Encouraging Health

EncouragingHealth.com shows a wide variety of issues and concerns about our health we all should be aware. Only when we are aware will we be able to make the necessary changes.

Through EncouragingHealth.com will be the education to invite ourselves to see our Health Care Providers, ask the questions and expect helpful answers.

EncouragingHealth.com will cover a wide variety of issues, concerns and helpful hints to lead healthy lives.

Encouraging Health Author(s)
    » Brick-ONeil

Science & Health Channel Posts

  • Gifts For Migraineurs
    'Tis the season and all that happy crappy. If you have migraines or chronic headaches, chances are most of your family does, too. Or perhaps you have a good friend or lover who happens to be a [...]
  • Russian Roulette
    Everyday we play Russian roulette with our health and well being. We eat things that we know aren’t good for us, in unhealthy portions. We smoke, drink and have unprotected sex. Always taking a [...]
  • Cards For The Depressed
    According to the National Insititute of Menatal Health, one in four adult Americans has a mental illness (including all of the types of depression). This comes to about 57.7 million people. That's [...]
  • Thanksgiving Story
    This was probably the worst Thanksgiving I've had in a while.  I emerged from the bed all week only to go to the doctor on Monday, Urgent Care on Wednesday night and the Emergency Room on [...]
  • Diabetic Women More Likely to Die After Heart Attack
    Women younger than age 65 with diabetes tend to have worse cardiovascular risk profiles than diabetic men of the same age, leading to higher death rates following a heart attack, research [...]
  • How astronauts stay fit, on and off the planet
    A new exercise machine sent to space station functions like a weight machine Astronaut Clay Anderson says space travel is generally physically easy People can be accepted to space program even [...]
  • Bush, first lady mark World AIDS Day
    President says program has treated 2 million in disease-ravaged Africa President Bush says his presidential initiative has already met its goal of treating two million people with the deadly AIDS [...]
  • Nutritional Label Innuendoes
    In a nutritional whirlpool of claims - low fat! high in fiber! helps prevent disease! - it's hard to know what to believe and what to pass by. Some of these packaging remarks are regulated by the [...]
  • Health groups team up for tasty, diabetic-friendly cookbook
    “If you or a loved one has diabetes, you need to eat heart-healthy meals,” says the back cover of a new cookbook for diabetics and those who eat with them. “To stay on track, you need [...]
  • Twix and pizza — are these really diet foods?
    Don't judge a food by its glycemic index. A guide to good and bad carbs Here's a riddle: What do a Twix candy bar, a Pizza Hut supreme pizza, and a Betty Crocker chocolate cake have in [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Episode 5X09: Me and My Town
    Good morning, everyone. How about that episode last night? Now that is what I’m talking about. In case you missed it, don’t worry! I’m about to give you a run down. Let’s start off with Susan [...]
  • Vanna Bonta Has a Wild Thanksgiving
    Hello guys! Belated Happy Thanksgiving. Now that we’ve mentioned thanksgiving, our feature for today is another guest post about Vanna Bonta; her thanksgiving holiday. So here goes [...]
  • The Week That Was
    This was a rather askew week for fantasy football and the NFL alike, mostly as a result of a fucking monsoon devastating the 4PM and Sunday night games taking place in the eastern time zone, but it [...]
  • Bush, first lady mark World AIDS Day
    President says program has treated 2 million in disease-ravaged Africa President Bush says his presidential initiative has already met its goal of treating two million people with the deadly AIDS [...]
  • Brad On The Cover of Architectural Digest
    I'm loving this photo of Brad on the cover of Architectural Digest, even though it looks highly photoshopped...this is the magazine that will be on stands in January of 2009 (wow does that sound [...]
  • Nutritional Label Innuendoes
    In a nutritional whirlpool of claims - low fat! high in fiber! helps prevent disease! - it's hard to know what to believe and what to pass by. Some of these packaging remarks are regulated by the [...]
  • Photo: Dwight Meets Gareth
    Rainn Wilson and Mackenzie Crook both played the same parts in The Office. Rainn does Dwight in the USA version, while MacKenzie does Gareth in the original BBC version. Last November 18th, [...]
  • UK Singles Chart New Music Videos
    ALESHA DIXON - "THE BOY DOES NOTHING" GEORGE SAMPSON - "HEADZ UP" [...]
  • Russian Roulette
    Everyday we play Russian roulette with our health and well being. We eat things that we know aren’t good for us, in unhealthy portions. We smoke, drink and have unprotected sex. Always taking a [...]
  • Michelle Ray Smith Returning to Guiding Light
    Michelle Ray Smith (Ava) will be returning to Guiding Light for a quick visit doing the Christmas holiday. [...]